Publishing

Self-publishing vs. traditional publishing: how to choose the right route for your book

By The Melon Publishers team 3 min read

Hand-coloured etching of an author and a bookseller in a bookshop full of books
Thomas Rowlandson, Bookseller and Author, 1784. Art Institute of Chicago, public domain.

Rights, control, timelines and reach: an honest comparison of self-publishing and traditional publishing, and the warning signs to look out for along the way.

There is no single right way to publish a book. Traditional publishing and self-publishing suit different books, different authors and different goals. This guide compares them honestly so you can choose with your eyes open.

How traditional publishing works

In traditional publishing, a publishing house buys the right to publish your book. It pays for editing, design, printing and distribution, and pays you a royalty on each copy sold, often with an advance paid before publication.

For most fiction and many nonfiction books, the route to a large publisher is through a literary agent. You query agents with a letter and sample chapters; if one takes you on, they submit your book to publishers. Smaller independent presses often accept submissions directly.

What you gain: professional editing and design at no cost to you, print distribution into bookstores, and the credibility of a known publisher.

What you give up: you license some of your rights to the publisher, you have less control over the cover, title and price, and the process is slow. Finding an agent and a publisher can take a long time, and publication itself often follows a year or more after the deal is signed.

How self-publishing works

In self-publishing, you are the publisher. You hire your own editor and designer (or do the work yourself), publish through platforms such as Amazon KDP and IngramSpark, and keep all of the rights and royalties.

What you gain: full control, speed, a higher share of each sale, and the freedom to publish books a traditional publisher might consider too niche.

What you give up: you pay for production yourself, physical bookstore placement is harder, and all of the marketing is your responsibility.

Side by side

Traditional Self-publishing
Who pays for production The publisher You
Rights Licensed to the publisher You keep them
Creative control Shared Yours
Speed to publication Usually slow As fast as you are ready
Share of each sale Smaller royalty, possibly an advance Larger royalty, no advance
Bookstore placement Easier Harder
Marketing Shared, mostly yours anyway Yours

What about hybrid and "assisted" publishing?

Between the two sits a wide range of companies that offer publishing services for a fee. Some are excellent: they give authors professional editing, design and distribution while the author keeps the rights. Others are vanity publishers that charge high fees, keep rights, and deliver little.

Warning signs

  • They promise bestseller status, guaranteed sales or "being on every bookstore shelf".
  • They want you to sign over rights for a long time, or the rights terms are unclear.
  • The contract does not say exactly what you will receive.
  • They pressure you to decide quickly, or praise every manuscript without reading it.
  • You cannot see real books they have produced, or talk to their authors.

A reputable service tells you what it will and will not do, puts it in writing, and leaves the rights with you. See our publishing fraud alert for more on avoiding scams.

How to choose

Ask yourself three questions:

  1. How much control do I want? If the cover, title and timing matter a lot to you, self-publishing gives you that control.
  2. How quickly do I want the book out? If timing matters, for a business book, an event or a personal milestone, self-publishing is much faster.
  3. Who are my readers and where do they buy books? Genres that sell mainly online, such as romance, thrillers and fantasy, often do very well self-published. Books that rely on bookstore and library placement can benefit from a traditional publisher.

Many authors do both over a career: publishing some books traditionally and others themselves.

Getting help with self-publishing

If you decide to self-publish, you do not have to do it alone. Our book publishing services cover editing, cover design, formatting, distribution and marketing, and you keep 100% of your rights. Tell us about your book and we will give you an honest view of the best route for it.

Written by The Melon Publishers team

Melon Publishers is a book publishing company based in the USA, working with authors around the world on writing, editing, design, publishing and marketing. Our blog shares reading lists and practical, honest advice for readers and writers.

More from the blog

See all articles
Painting of a quiet snow-covered road lined with bare trees Book Lists

Novels to get lost in this winter

By The Melon Publishers team

Historical fiction that spans three centuries, a mystery about the stories we tell, a magical adventure and a snowy animal escapade for long winter evenings.

Ready to publish your book?

Tell us about your manuscript and where you are in the process. We will reply with honest, practical next steps.