Editing

Beta readers: what they are, where to find them and how to use their feedback

By The Melon Publishers team 2 min read

Painting of the poet Virgil reading his Aeneid aloud to Augustus, Octavia and Livia
Jean-Baptiste Wicar, Virgil Reading the Aeneid to Augustus, Octavia, and Livia, 1790–93. Art Institute of Chicago, public domain.

Beta readers tell you how your book feels to a real reader. How to find good ones, what to ask them and what to do with what they say.

A beta reader is someone who reads your manuscript before it is published and tells you how it felt to read. They are not editors and not proofreaders. Their value is simple: they show you what a real reader experiences, which is the one thing you cannot see for yourself.

When to use beta readers

After you have revised your draft yourself, and before you pay for a full professional edit. Beta feedback can reveal big problems (a confusing opening, a character nobody likes, an ending that falls flat) that are much cheaper to fix before editing begins.

Who makes a good beta reader

  • Readers of your genre. Someone who reads ten thrillers a year knows what a thriller should feel like.
  • People who will be honest. Close family often are not, out of kindness.
  • A mix of readers. Three to six readers give you patterns, not just opinions.

Look in writing groups, genre reading communities, local libraries and among readers who already follow your work.

What to ask them

Open questions work better than "did you like it?". For example:

  • Where did you lose interest, even briefly?
  • Was anything confusing?
  • Which characters did you care about, and which did you not?
  • Did the ending feel earned?
  • What do you think the book is about?

Give them a deadline, and tell them what kind of feedback you do not need yet, such as typos.

Making sense of the feedback

One reader's opinion is a data point; the same comment from three readers is a pattern. Focus on patterns. Notice where readers felt something was wrong, even if their suggested fix is not right; a reader is usually accurate about the problem and less reliable about the solution.

Thank every reader, whether or not you use their advice.

After beta readers

Revise, then choose the right level of professional editing. Our book editing team will read a sample and recommend the edit your manuscript needs.

Written by The Melon Publishers team

Melon Publishers is a book publishing company based in the USA, working with authors around the world on writing, editing, design, publishing and marketing. Our blog shares reading lists and practical, honest advice for readers and writers.

More from the blog

See all articles

Ready to publish your book?

Tell us about your manuscript and where you are in the process. We will reply with honest, practical next steps.